I like the idea, but I think it is a little too exclusive for a forum. I really think people quickly and easily pick up on our shared values regarding dogs by just reading through threads. Some don't catch on as quick and are put-off, but most recognize that some beliefs are shared by the majority, and they'll be on the outs if they don't agree, leaving them with the decision on what stance to take for themselves.
It's funny how the majority of us do hold the same beliefs, and we all know that regular participants are in agreement with those beliefs, even though we've never sat around talking about what's wrong and right in regards to dogs.
